5 Best Broiler Pans of 2021 Compared & Reviewed

Best Broiler Pan
Photo: Nordic Ware

One of the ways that you can boost healthy cooking in your home is buying the best broiler pan. This is because this pan is made in such a way that it ensures that all nutrients and minerals in your food remain intact during and after cooking.

A broiler pan is used in the oven where the heat originates from the top. As a result, food cooked in a broiler pan is usually evenly cooked. Moreover, almost all broiler pans are made with a nonstick surface, reducing the amount of oil used when cooking.

Therefore, if you want to upgrade the value of your kitchen by buying a reliable broiler pan, here is the ultimate guide and 5 broiler pans review to help you make an informed decision.

What to Check Before Buying Best Broiler Pan?

How to Buy the Best Broiler Pan

1. Versatility

This is a critical factor that should be considered when buying the best broiler pan. It determines how many meals that the product can prepare. Some broiler pans can only cook meat while others are desired to cook snacks only.

However, there are models that cook almost everything and these give you perfect value for your money. Therefore, try and buy a product that will serve you more than one purpose in order for you to save money in the long run.

2. Size

Size is an important factor that you must consider when buying a broiler pan. This is because the size determines how well the product will fit in your oven. Hence, before buying a broiler pan, you must put into consideration the size of your own as well.

Additionally, the size of the broiler pan is critical to consider before paying for any product because it determines the capacity and surface area of the pan.

Broiler pans with small size are highly portable, but they cannot prepare a large amount of meals. Therefore, you must consider what you should prioritize in order to buy a pan that will match your needs.

3. Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning is a task that everyone tries to avoid whenever possible. This is why you should look for a broiler pan that is easy to clean and maintain, especially if the product is being used on a daily basis.

To save yourself a lot of time, effort and detergent when cleaning a broiler pan, get one that is dishwasher safe.

Additionally, a broiler pan that features a nonstick surface is easy to clean and also uses less amount of oil when cooking.

4. Construction

The best broiler pan should feature a durable material, heavy-duty design and easy to clean. A broiler pan should boost heath cooking and for this reason, it should feature a high-quality material like steel or carbon that will not affect the quality of the food.

Additionally, broiler pans should have nonstick surfaces and this is mainly facilitated by a porcelain surface.

5. Purpose

One of the important things to consider when buying a broiler pan is the purpose of buying it. This translates to the type of food you intend to cook with the product. Will you often cook veggies or meat?

In case you intend to cook met most of the time, the best broiler pan for you is the one that features a grill-style rack. Alternatively, you can invest in a product that features grate with wide slits to enhance smooth drip penetration.

However, if you will often cook veggie as opposed to meat, buy a broiler pan with a high surface area at the top.

6. Budget

Here is a critical factor that always determines what you take home. You should invest in a broiler pan that will give you the best value for your money.

Therefore, regardless of whether you are running on a budget or you are in search of a high-end model, there is an ideal broiler pan for you on the market.

However, you should always ensure that the material making the product is safe to avoid risking your health. Therefore, extremely cheap broiler pans should be avoided as most of them have substandard materials and construction.

For you to buy a broiler pan of decent quality, buy an item that is between $10 and $50. With products between this price ranges, you can be sure that they feature food grade material and superior durability.

5 Best Broiler Pans of 2021 Reviewed




Nordic Ware 42210

1. Nordic Ware 42210 (Travel-friendly)

  • Travel-friendly with portable design
  • Aluminized steel material hence lightweight
  • Non-sticky property hence easy to clean
  • Heavy duty construction hence durable
Granite Ware 0542-2

2. Granite Ware 0542-2 (Excellent Heat Distribution)

  • Excellent heat distribution – Carbon steel material
  • Dishwasher safe hence easy to clean
  • 2 in 1 piece- broiler and roasting function
Range Kleen BP102X

3. Range Kleen BP102X (Guaranteed to Last)

  • Guaranteed to last
  • Dishwasher safe hence easy to clean
  • Perfectly sized
  • Tough built non-stick material – 1025 degrees F
Norpro 273

4. Norpro 273 (Safe & Healthy)

  • Safe and healthy – Stainless steel
  • Perforated top for draining grease
  • Dishwasher safe design hence easy to clean
  • Trendy design hence adds elegance
General Electric WB48X10056

5. General Electric WB48X10056 (Large Cooking Surface)

  • Large cooking surface
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Enameled steel material
  • Perforated top facilitates ventilation

1. Nordic Ware 42210 – Travel-friendly

Nordic Ware 42210
Photo: Nordic Ware

  • Core Materials: Aluminized Steel
  • Dimensions: 10 x 7 x 0.6 inches

Nordic Ware 42210 is the best broiler pan for traveling or camping. This is because it is suitable for use in RV stoves, camping stoves, and toaster ovens. Additionally, it is perfect for cooking meat in the backyard. Therefore, if you are a regular traveler, this broiler pan will be a perfect purchase.

It is made using an aluminized steel material, making it a light-weight construction that is easy for use. As a result, it becomes easy to transport it from one place to another during outdoor cooking. The material also heats up faster, saving you a lot of time when cooking.

Additionally, this material enhances the non-sticky property. As a result, it is a suitable pan for cooking different types of meals including sandwich, pizza, fish chips, fries, and shrimps. Moreover, the non-sticky feature of this product makes it easy to clean, saving you a lot of time and effort.

This broiler pan features a heavy-duty construction that gives it superior durability. It is also a product that is easy to use and maintain. Nonetheless, the product should be hand washed as it is not dishwasher safe.

Furthermore, it features a cooking surface that measures 8.5 x 6.5 inches. Therefore, it is a broiler pan that is perfect for preparing dishes of small proportions and light meals. Hence, it is a great purchase for preparing travel-friendly meals and for single use.


  • Easy to store as it has a compact design
  • Travel-friendly as it is highly portable
  • Easy to use and maintain
  • Gives long-lasting service due to heavy-duty construction


  • Unsuitable for large amounts of meals
  • Not dishwasher safe

2. Granite Ware 0542-2 – Excellent Heat Distribution

Granite Ware 0542-2
Photo: Granite Ware

  • Core Material: Carbon Steel
  • Dimensions: 19.2 x 12.2 x 2.2 inches

This 2-piece broiler set has excellent heat distribution as its distinctive feature. As a result, you can be sure that your meals will be evenly cooked from all surfaces when using this broiler pan.

Carbon steel is the material that makes the core part of this product. This material majorly boosts the uniform heat distribution function. The surface of the broiler pan, however, features porcelain surface, which is nonstick. Therefore, this is an easy to clean product that can cook various meals.

Moreover, this broiler pan is dishwasher safe and this makes it ideal for daily use. Hence, it is an easy to maintain product that does not demand a lot of your time or effort to keep clean after regular use.

When cooking meat, this pan facilitates even browning. The 2 in 1 piece has a broiler and roasting function. However, you might have to spend a little more on it, but it is worth the investment.


  • Uniform heat distribution
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Enhanced meat browning mechanism
  • Large cooking area


  • Relatively expensive
  • May not fit in small-sized ovens

3. Range Kleen BP102X – Guaranteed to Last

Range Kleen BP102X
Photo: Range Kleen

  • Core Material: Steel
  • Dimensions: 16 x 12.5 x 1.6 inches

This is the best broiler pan for oven that gives you a guarantee to last due to its superior durability. Mainly this is facilitated by the authentic rack made of super-tough porcelain coated steel that it comes with. 

It is a dishwasher safe broiler pan that is easy to clean and perfect for use on a daily basis. Therefore, it helps you save your cleaning detergent, time and effort. Additionally, its ease of cleaning is also boosted by the non-stick surface that it features.

This is a perfectly sized broiler pan whose size is ideal for cooking numerous meals. As a matter of fact, it is big enough to accommodate huge cuts and also compact enough for easy storage. Its perfect and compact size makes it easy to clean.

This broiler pan for oven features tough built non-stick material that you can use with high temperatures of up to 1025 degrees F. Hence, with this pan, you are free to crank up the oven and let it handle the rest. 


  • Heavy-duty construction boosts durability
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Withstands high temperatures – 1025 degrees F
  • Perfect for daily use


  • Top part requires hand-washing

4. Norpro 273 – Safe & Healthy

Norpro 273
Photo: Norpro

  • Core Material: Stainless Steel
  • Dimensions: 12 x 9 x 1.5 inches

This is the top-rated broiler pan for boosting safety and health when cooking the modern-day meals. The product features stainless steel material that promotes safety as its nonstick nature needs minimal oil usage when cooking.

The product features a perforated top that facilitates the draining of grease when cooking. Hence, this broiler pan separates food from excess fat and oils, making it one of the best for healthy cooking.

Therefore, you can use this product to prepare foods like bread, shell-fish, fish, chicken, and beef among other fatty meals without putting your health at risk.

This best stainless steel broiler pan features a dishwasher safe design. As a result, it requires little or no effort when cleaning it. The cleaning process also takes less time as compared to hand washed products. Additionally, the capacity to machine this broiler pan implies that it is perfect for daily use.

It comes with a trendy design and this implies that it not only features a top-notch performance when cooking but also comes along with a decorative function. Hence, this is a product that will add elegance to your kitchen.

Nonetheless, this broiler pan features a small size and this implies that it is not perfect for preparing large amounts of food.


  • Boosts healthy cooking
  • Strong and stable construction
  • Easy to clean and maintained
  • Cooks different types of meals


  • Unsuitable for preparing large food proportions
  • Tray fits loosely

5. General Electric WB48X10056 – Large Cooking Surface

General Electric WB48X10056
Photo: General Electric

  • Core Material: Enameled Steel
  • Dimensions: 18.2 x 15.7 x 3 inches

This is the best nonstick broiler pan that you should buy when cooking a large amount of food. This is because it features a large cooking surface making it ideal for cooking for many people.

It is a dishwasher safe broiler pan that allows you to save a huge amount of your cleaning detergent as it is easy to clean. Moreover, this dishwasher safe feature also ensures that you can save a lot of your time and effort when cleaning, making it perfect for daily use.

The product is made of enameled steel material that gives it a heavy-duty construction. Therefore, you can be sure that it comes with superior durability and longevity. Hence, it gives you perfect value for your money as it serves you for ages before needing replacement.

Its top is perforated and this facilitates ventilation. As a result, this functionality boosts the efficiency of the nonstick feature of this product. Hence, it comes with the capability of separating excess fats from meals.

The structure and size of this product are perfect but does not often fit in all ovens. This is especially when using a small sized oven. Hence, you need at least a medium-sized oven in order for it to be fully accommodated.


  • Large cooking area for large meals
  • Long lasting design
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Uses less oil when cooking


  • Does not fit in small ovens
  • Sharp edges can be inconvenient when handling

Broiling Pan vs Roasting Pan

Broiling Pan vs. Roasting Pan

Both broiling and roasting pans are kitchen cookware but each one of them features specific uses and properties. Additionally, both of them are used with extremely high temperatures. Some pans feature both functions while others can only deliver one function.

Anodized aluminum and stainless steel are the commonly used materials to make both pans. Iron or enameled steel are also common materials that you can find on the market.

1. Broiling Pan

Broiling pans are used in the oven where the heat originates from the top. They feature a slotted top, and they are also shallow. Moreover, broiling pans have two distinct parts.

The slotted upper part is used for food while the other part is placed underneath to collect drippings. Food should be adequately marinated before using a broiling pan 


  • Easy to clean especially if the product is made of glass as opposed to metal
  • Separates food from excess fat
  • Ideal for food that contains excess fat


  • The broiler pan setting is adjusted by the cook
  • Mainly used to cook less quantity of meat due to shallow depth
  • Sometimes food is not uniformly cooked

2. Roasting pans

Used when heat originates from both the top and bottom of the oven and are deeper than compared to their broiling counterparts. Additionally, roasting pans feature single parts.

However, some models feature a rack, responsible for raising it when cooking while others have a covering lid. Roasting pans are only used to cook meals that should not be separated from their juices.


  • The desired temperature is programmed
  • Used to cook large amounts of meals
  • Food is always evenly cooked


  • Only cooks food that should not be separated from its juice


Buying the top-notch broiler pan should no longer be overwhelming or hectic. With these broiler pan reviews and ultimate guide, picking your best choice should be effortless and fun.

All the products reviewed above feature high quality as well as durability. Therefore, you should select any of them that match your need, purpose, lifestyle, and budget.