5 Best Cookie Presses of 2021 Compared & Reviewed

Best Cookie Press
Photo: OXO

Cookies are not just made at home when Christmas is near. It is a daily part of your life. While many people prefer buying cookies from the bakery, some of us like to put our cookie making artistic skills in practice to bake cookies at home. One of the mandatory tools is the best cookie press that is used to make the cookies.

Buyers should keep an eye open for the number of discs it has and the material used in the making. Well, in this cookie press review, you will get all the information you need in selecting the right model for cookie making. Pay attention!

How to Buy the Best Cookie Press
Photo: Wilton

Whether you are planning to buy the best electric cookie press or the manual model, there are some significant details that you should note.

In this section, we will share some tips on how to the best cookie press online.

1. Manual or Electric Cookie Press

Without any further ado, let’s discuss both these models in detail:

Manual Cookie Press: You will see that the market it loaded with the manual models. People like them for many reasons. Some of them will be easy availability, less complexity in usage, and affordability.

These models are quite straightforward and can handle the tough dough as well. The counterparts usually fail to work with the hard dough. You will also find some of the best professional cookie presses to be manual.

Since these machines are not bound by electricity, you can use them whenever and wherever you want.

Electric Cookie Press: The alternative option is of electric press. Since mechanical mechanism is involved, you can expect more consistent cookies.

These presses run on electricity, so you cannot use it when there is a power cut. Of course, these are powered with electricity and no manual force is used, so the price is higher than the counterpart.

Not many people prefer the electric versions because first they take all the fun off and secondly, the high cost doesn’t seem so meaningful.

Buying Advice

You can make your own choice. The electric models only give consistent cookies. Whereas the manual model is decently priced and more robust and fun.

2. Die-Cut Discs

It is very difficult to make one cookie at a time. So, the next essential thing to check is the number of discs available with a press. Most of the cookie press offer 12 discs.

Also, it is best to choose a model that has different shapes available on cookie discs. Some of the common patterns that you can get in the discs are flowers, butterflies, and hearts. This way, the taste and design of the cookies will be remarkable.

3. Shaft Capacity

The increase in the shaft capacity will call for lesser number of refills for cookie making. However, if you want to enjoy baking cookies with your kids then plan for the smaller shaft capacity that they are able to handle.

Of course, you will have to make frequent refills, but your kids will have fun during the baking session.

4. Material

Most of the cookie presses are made with two prime materials. The outside or the frame of the appliance is usually made of plastic. It streamlines the overall cost of the tool as well.

The discs are usually made of either plastic or metal. Plastic material is not as effective and durable as the metal ones.

In metal also, you should make sure that it is rust free and corrosion resistant. The metals that catches rust will ruin your experience of baking cookies. Stainless steel is the finest material because it requires no maintenance and stay completely away from rusting and corrosion.

If you want the best spritz cookie press then make sure it has stainless steel discs. This material will be the best suitable for the spritz cookies as they are difficult to hold than other cookies.

5. Ease to Clean

After every use, a cookie press will demand cleaning. It is important that you buy a product that is easy to clean and require less maintenance.

You have to take apart the entire machine and clean it. The finest models are the ones that does not have extremely hard-to-reach areas to make cleaning complex.




OXO Good Grips

1. OXO Good Grips (Top-rated)

  • 12 cookies discs
  • Manual cookie press
  • Made with plastic and stainless steel
  • Comes with a storage case for cookie discs
Cuisinart CCP-10

2. Cuisinart CCP-10 (High-performance Electric Design)

  • 12 cookies discs
  • Electric cookie press
  • Made with plastic and stainless steel
  • Comes with 3-years warranty
Wilton Simple Success

3. Wilton Simple Success (Most-affordable)

  • 12 cookies discs
  • Manual cookie press
  • Made with plastic
Wilton Preferred Press

4. Wilton Preferred Press (Fine Machine for Spritz Cookies)

  • 12 cookies discs
  • Manual cookie press
  • Made with plastic and metal
  • Has raised-base design
Edge Cook Cookie Press

5. Edge Cook Cookie Press (With Maximum Accessories)

  • 20 cookies discs
  • Manual cookie press
  • Made with Stainless steel
  • Comes with 1-year replacement guaranteed

1. OXO Good Grips – Top-rated

OXO Good Grips
Photo: OXO

  • Cookie Disc: 12
  • Material: Stainless Steel & Plastic

OXO has raised the bar to a huge extent with this brilliant cookie press. It is a simple manual product that is made of a combination of plastic and stainless-steel material. The disc material is the finest one and does not rust or corrode with time. It requires the least maintenance.

There are 12 discs available with this model available in various shapes like daisy, sunflower, fleur-de-lis, butterfly, bear, shell, leaf, heart, snowflake, tree, and wrath. This is a great product to buy for Christmas and enjoy cookie making with your kids.

This model can be used to make consistent cookies in every use. The non-slip base of the press keeps it sturdy and glued at one place while dispensing dough.

You have to pull the lever to make cookies, and it is quite comfortable for repeated usage. Because of the clear cylinder frame, you can keep check on the amount of dough remained in the cookie press.

This is a fantastic machine however you will need some practice understanding smooth usage. So, try not to buy it close to an event in case you have to take some practice days and batches. Also, the handle material is not as robust.


  • Releases consistent cookies every time
  • Stainless steel discs are durable
  • Clear frame to keep check on remaining dough
  • A fine gift for Christmas


  • User will require some practice to expert using this machine
  • The handle material could have been better

2. Cuisinart CCP-10 – Best-High-performance

Cuisinart CCP-10
Photo: Cuisinart

  • Cookie Disc: 12
  • Material: Stainless Steel & Plastic

So, for someone who wants an electric model, this is the Cuisinart cookie press which is innovative and one of its kind. This model is manufactured with plastic and stainless-steel material. It has uncompromised quality and has 3-years warranty to safeguard your purchase.

It has 12 discs shaped differently. To give you better baking experience, it is also gifted with 8 stainless steel decorating tips. You can make cookies in versatile styles. The dimensions of the disc are 3-4/5 x 3-4/5 x 9 inches. This will make standard sized cookies.

Being an electric model, you can expect great consistency from this machine. It has one touch operation for a smooth and consistent flow. The clear tube gives you a see-through to the remaining dough in the machine.

The price of this model is extremely high which can prevent many buyers from making the purchase. Also, the plastic used in its making could have been a lot better than the one it has.


  • Comes with 12 stainless steel discs and 8 decorating tips
  • Very consistent cookies made with the press
  • One-touch working of the machine
  • Smooth usage of the machine


  • The price of this model is too high
  • Plastic used is of cheap quality

3. Wilton Simple Success – Most-affordable

Wilton Simple Success
Photo: Wilton

  • Cookie Disc: 12
  • Material: Plastic

So, if you are an occasional user and don’t want to spend a lot of money on a cookie press then this manual model from Wilton can be a good fit. It is among the most economically priced models in our list.

The material used for the frame and the discs is plastic. There are 12 plastic-made discs readily available with this purchase.

They are designed differently in various shapes like Christmas tree, wreath and snowman, pumpkin, turkey and other routine designs like dot pattern, doily, pinwheel, heart, starburst, sunburst and biscuit.

The comfortable and ergonomic handle offer comfortable grip to the user. The machine offers fast and easy release of cookies. You don’t need any pre-practice to use this model.

Through the clear barrel, you can watch when the batter is finished in the machine. You are required to use warm soapy water after every used to clean the machine.

The plastic material used for the discs is not durable. Also, the overall quality could have been better. However, the small price completely justifies the lacking quality of the press. Also, there is no warranty with this model.


  • No practice required to use the machine
  • Comes with variable shapes of the discs
  • Clear barrel to keep check on the remaining batter


  • Does not have any warranty
  • The overall quality is low

4. Wilton Preferred Press – Fine Machine for Spritz Cookies

Wilton Preferred Press
Photo: Wilton

  • Cookie Disc: 12
  • Material: Plastic & Metal

So, this other model from Wilton is more popular among the buyers. This is also a manual cookie press used by pressing the lever. The machine is decently priced and is made of a combination of plastic and metal for durability.

It also comprises 12 discs made of combination metal. It is rust-resistant to a large extent but does require some maintenance.

The translucent plastic frame gives you an insight on the remaining batter in the machine. The working mechanism of this model is the same as any other standard cookie press.

Something that could be a matter of concern here is that if the batter turns out to be too hard then repeated pressing might break the handle. Also, metal material require maintenance.


  • Discs are available in a couple of different shapes
  • Decent quality of the machine
  • One of the most decently priced products
  • Good for everyday use as well


  • Metal material require maintenance
  • The handle is a little fragile
Edge Cook Cookie Press
Photo: Edge Cook

  • Cookie Disc: 20
  • Material: Stainless Steel

This product from Edge Cook has the most robust construction with stainless steel material all over. It is a likable manual machine with easy operations and great output.

This product is equipped with 20 discs and 8 icing tips. You will enjoy all these accessories to streamline your experience. The shapes of the discs are quite interesting and delightful, especially for festival cookies.

The ergonomic handle is quite robust and durable. It can handle a tough better as well. This is a great overall machine.

The tube is not see-through, so you might have to guess the refilling of the batter. Also, this model is recommended to be washed with hand. Don’t put it inside a dishwasher or else the construction will be hampered.


  • Robust and durable construction
  • Comes with 20 discs and 8 icing tips
  • Easy and smooth to use
  • Great overall machine for cookie making


  • The frame is not see-though
  • This appliance is not dishwash friendly


We rest our cookie press review with the last words that this is an essential machine for all the cookie makers. Selecting it has become easier than ever with our review.

Now you know all the essential features to look in the best machine. Moreover, to help you make direct purchase, we have made some strong recommendations.

Choose any product from the suggestion, and you will never have to regret making the choice.