When you begin the research for the best pizza stone, there are some quintessential features you want to consider in the purchase. It is mostly related to the size, shape, material, durability, and handling of the product.
Among other materials, cordierite is heavily popular among buyers. This is because it evenly cooks the pizza, absorb the moisture and give the crunchiest crust.
Certainly, you want to consider all the essential elements for a successful purchase. This review will help you determine the strengths and weaknesses of the top models on the market and give you right information to find the best product.
What to Check Before Buying Best Pizza Stone?
So, in order to find the best pizza stone, it is important to know all the crucial details about it. We share the tips to find the best models in the market.
1. Types of Pizza Stones
Basically, there are three types of pizza stone that you can find online.
Cordierite Pizza Stones: Well, if you want to bake more than pizzas then cordierite is the best material to purchase. These are extremely durable and thermal shock-resistant, thus making the handling super easy.
These are available in rectangle or round shape. Thus, these can easily fit the ovens. You can also keep them inside the oven, even when they are not in use.
The downside is that these are little expensive. But to cover that factor, you get extreme durability. This material also doesn’t break or crack even when put in extremely high temperature.
Clay Pizza Stone: The best thing about the stone or clay pizza stone is that it is the best in absorbing moisture. It is also the finest for imitating the masonry oven.
These stones are available in various shapes. It is easy to make clay pizza stone at home. But if you don’t want to do so, you can easily purchase it online.
With everything else so well with this type, the only downside is that since you have to preheat the oven for around 30-minutes before cooking, these can break or crack soon. These are also very difficult to clean.
Ceramic Pizza Stone: If you want to buy something cost-effective then ceramic pizza stone is an ideal choice. This material is easy to handle . Plus, it is easy to clean.
Technically, it is made of clay and fired with kiln. Thus, these stones conduct high heat and spread it evenly throughout the stone for perfect baking.
There is durability concern with this material but other than that, everything with this material is great.
Our best recommendation of ceramic stone is the Emile Henry 787514 pizza stone.
Buying Advice: Still wondering which is the best pizza stone for oven? Well, according to use, without a doubt it is the cordierite. While it is expensive but all other pros of the material outweigh the high cost.
2. Size & Shape
To be honest, this completely depends on the need of an individual. As far as size is concerned, you should first determine the size of the oven or grill in which the pizza stone will be used.
The size of a pizza stone can be as little as 13-inches in diameter and it can go as high as 18 to 20-inches.
Most people prefer purchasing a medium-sized stone which is 16-inches that is suitable for different types of families.
As far as shape is concerned, you can make a purchase based on the shape that you admire in a pizza stone.
Every pizza stone has a certain level of thickness that makes it more durable and tough. The thickness of the material of the stone allow it to endure more heat, without breaking or cracking.
You should make sure that the stone is decently thick so that it can last for a longer time. Old Stone 4461 pizza stone has suitable thickness for better heat-resistance.
10 Best Pizza Stones of 2021 Reviewed
|1. CastElegance Pizza Stone (Best Overall)|
|2. Old Stone 4467 (Made of Lead-Free Clay)|
|3. Old Stone 4461 (Clay Stone with High Heat Resistance)|
|4. NerdChef NC-SS25 (Most-Durable)|
|5. Love This Kitchen LTK-PIZZA-R16 (Core Convection Technology)|
|6. Emile Henry 787514 (10-Year Guarantee)|
|7. Heritage Black Ceramic (Lightweight)|
|8. Cuisinart CPS-013 (Most-Affordable)|
|9. Wilton 2105-0244 (With Chrome Lifting Rack)|
|10. Solido SYNCHKG100421 (Highly Compatible)|
1. CastElegance Pizza Stone – Best Overall
- Dimensions: 16 x 5/8-inches
- Material: Cordierite
- Weight: 9.1-pounds
There are plentiful reasons that make this model the best overall product on the list. Firstly, it is constructed with a superior material cordierite. Furthermore, it comes with various safety certifications from FDA, European Union, German Food, Code, and RoHS.
The thermarite absorbs maximum moisture while giving you a crispy base of the pizza. The material is also suitable for shock retention.
Unlike other models, you can use this one with the grill or an oven. Also, it has great heat retention.
The only downside is that the company failed to offer any warranty with this product.
- Comes with multiple safety certifications and made with cordierite material
- Does not smell
- Compatible with grill and oven
- Suitable for shock retention
- No warranty
2. Old Stone 4467 – Lead-Free Clay Pizza Stone
- Dimensions: 14.5 x 16.5-inches
- Material: Clay
- Weight: 10-pounds
The key point of this product is that it is made with lead-free clay material. It is safe in usage and will not release any odor in the pizza.
It comes in 14.5 x 16.5-inches dimensions which is suitable for most ovens. Since it is raised from the bottom, you can conveniently pick it up after usage.
Other than pizzas, this stone is equally great in making pastries and cookies as well.
On the downside, the thickness of this model is merely 0.8-inches which does not allow it to endure a lot of heat. There is a possibility of stone cracking from between due to overheating.
Considering the fact that the price is suitable, you can consider purchasing this model for occasional baking.
- Made of lead-free clay
- Decently priced
- Fit all kinds of ovens
- Suitable for baking cookies and pastries as well
- Not durable because of the thinness
3. Old Stone 4461 – Best with High Heat Resistance
- Dimensions: 16 x 3.3-inches
- Material: Clay
- Weight: 0.01-pounds
Unlike the former model from Old Stone, this one has 3.3-inches thickness and has high heat-resisting potential of up to 2000 degrees F. It evenly spreads the heat on the stone for perfect pizza-making experience.
The diameter of this model is 16-inches which is suitable for many ovens.
With the heat core technology, the stone eliminates soggy centres of the pizza. You can expect restaurant like taste and crisp from the pizzas as this model can largely eliminate the moisture while baking.
Other than being a great product for making pizzas, with this you can also bake bread, biscuits, pastries, etc. Unfortunately, the brand commits no warranty with this product.
- 3.3-inches thickness for high heat-resistance
- Suitable for differently sized ovens
- Comes with heat core technology
- Does not come with any warranty
4. NerdChef NC-SS25 – Most-Durable
- Dimensions: 16 x 14.25 x 0.25-inches
- Material: Strong Steel
- Weight: 16-pounds
Being constructed with steel material, this is the most durable product on the list. The low-friction surface is textured and sanded smooth. It is also seasoned with flaxseed oil for more enhanced baking.
It can be used for baking pizzas and other savouries since it has 20 times higher conductivity than ceramic baking stones. The heat is supplied evenly on the base. But you have to be very vigilant while holding the stone after baking. This can be pretty hot.
Unlike other clay-based models, it is easy to clean and does not require a lot of maintenance either. The rectangular shaped pizza stone is suitable for variably sized ovens because of its dimensions 16 x 14.25 x 0.25-inches.
If we talk about the downside, that will be extreme heft in weight which is 16-pounds and the high cost of this product.
- Most durable pizza stone
- Flaxseed oil seasoned
- Suitable for making different savories
- Higher conductivity
- Very heavy
5. Love This Kitchen LTK-PIZZA-R16 – Best with Core Convection Technology
- Dimensions: 17 x 16 x 0.9-inches
- Material: Cordierite
- Weight: 8.8-pounds
Most people have complaints that the pizzas don’t cook as well from the center. Well, this model comes with core convection technology that pulls the heat inwards, ensuring even baking of pizza from all sides.
It is constructed with cordierite material and is lightweight than many competitive models. Also, this one is FDA-approved to give you safe cooking experience.
The ThermaShock technology makes sure that the stone does not break from between due to extreme temperature changes. It has heat retention to up to 1500 degrees F.
What might bother some buyers is the chemical that is coated on the surface. While it is safe in consumption, it might hamper the taste of your pizza.
- Core convection technology
- Size easily fits in standard ovens
- Relatively lightweight
- Durability ensured with ThermoShock technology
- The chemical coated on the surface might change the taste of pizza
6. Emile Henry 787514 – Best with 10-Year Guarantee
- Dimensions: 14.5 x 14.5 x 2.5-inches
- Material: Ceramic
- Weight: 5.7-pounds
Companies don’t usually take guarantee of a product like pizza stones as they are so prone of breaking due to mishandling. However, this one is a little different from the lot as it comes with 10-year guarantee.
Within this period, if anything happens to the product, you can claim a replacement stone from the company.
This model is made with all-natural materials and manufactured using high standards of flame technology.
It is safe on using gas, charcoal, natural wood, oven, grill, etc. This can bear heat up to 900 degrees F. The size is suitable to fit inside a standard oven and grill.
There is glazed coating on the surface of the product which is scratch-resistant. This coating also contributes in making extremely crispy pizzas.
The lightweight of this model allows you to take it as you go out for a picnic. As it can be conveniently used on the wooden grills as well, you can make pizzas with this pizzas stone in any kind of outdoor settings.
As far as cleaning is concerned, this model is dishwasher friendly. You can also conveniently clean it manually with soap and water.
The only downside is that it is expensive than various competitive models on the market.
- Comes with 10-year guarantee
- Coated with glazed material
- Bit pricey
7. Heritage Black Ceramic – Lightweight
- Dimensions: 15.79 x 15.79 x 2.48-inches
- Material: Ceramic
- Weight: 3.15-pounds
The USP of this pizza stone is that it is lightweight and weighs merely 3.15-pounds.
It can pre-heat 2 times faster than other conventional pizza stones. You can use it on various heating units. You can place it on wooden or charcoal grills as well.
Another good thing about this model is that it does not smoke at all. There are no chemical coatings on the top that can make pizzas unfit to consume. At the same time, it will also not stain from grease.
One thing that we didn’t like about this product is that it is not scratch-resistant. If you cut the pizza on the stone, the scratches will immediately appear on the surface.
- Extremely lightweight and easy to handle
- Compatible with various heating units
- Not scratch-resistant
8. Cuisinart CPS-013 – Most-Affordable
- Dimensions: 13 x 13 x 0.8-inches
- Material: Cordierite
- Weight: 3.45-pounds
Cuisinart is one of the leading brands to manufacture pizza stones and other kitchen appliances. This product comes with high brand value on an affordable price.
It is made of cordierite material. The size is a little disappointing because it is too small for making a decent-size pizza. It warms up instantly.
As far as performance is concerned, the heat is thoroughly and evenly supplied to all the parts of the product. Thus, it is suitable for baking, bread, cookies, calzones, desserts, etc.
One more thing that you might not like about this product is that it doesn’t have raised feet that can make taking it out of the over easy.
- Most affordable pizza stone
- Even heat-distribution
- High brand value
- Size is too small
- Does not have raised platform for easy holding
9. Wilton 2105-0244 – Best with Chrome Lifting Rack
- Dimensions: 15-inches
- Material: Ceramic
- Weight: 3.04-pounds
Wilton pizza stone is a standard product that has all basic features of a good pizza stone. However, its unique point is the chrome lifting rack that makes it different from other products on the list. It makes taking the stone in an out of the oven very convenient.
It has great tendency to absorb the moisture. This way, you can expect great crispy pizzas. Surely, no one likes soggy pizza base, so you will be highly satisfied in this case.
The 15-inches diameter of the stone is suitable to fit easily in a grill or oven. You can also use it with various other heating units.
The heat retention tendency of this model is high. Furthermore, It comes with 1-year warranty. However, the color is too light, and it will show stains and grease marks on the stone.
- Comes with chrome lifting racks
- Less in weight
- High tendency to absorb moisture
- Comes with 1-year warranty
- Light color will show grease marks on the stone
10. Solido SYNCHKG100421 – Highly Compatible
- Dimensions: 14 x 16 x 1.1-inches
- Material: Cordierite
- Weight: 13.35-pounds
The shining point of this product is that it is highly compatible with different cooking surfaces like oven, grill, and BBQ. The cordierite material make it a suitable choice among buyers.
It is available in rectangular shape and can easily slip inside a standard sized oven or grill as it comes in 14 x 16 x 1.1-inches dimensions.
You can bake pizza, bread, or even cookies on this pizza stone. It has a unique heat spiral and has beautifully crafted feet to give optimum balance to the product. This way, it also gets superior grip.
What you might not like about the product is that its color is too light which might adapt the oil marks.
- Compatible with grill, BBQ and oven
- Provide superior grip
- Used for making cookies, pizza, and breads
- Oil marks will appear due to light color
We would like to sign off from the pizza stone review saying that whether you are an occasional pizza maker or frequent, the pizza stones come handy in the process to relish the authentic taste.
Our best recommendation is the CastElegance pizza stone which comes with a mammoth of safety certifications and claims that this one is the safest product to use.
You can also find differently sized pizza stones to suit your needs. Since most people plan to purchase a product that can last the longest, they can prefer purchasing the NerdChef NC-SS25 pizza stone which is the most durable product on the list.
In this post:
- What to Check Before Buying Best Pizza Stone?
- 10 Best Pizza Stones of 2021 Reviewed
- 1. CastElegance Pizza Stone – Best Overall
- 2. Old Stone 4467 – Lead-Free Clay Pizza Stone
- 3. Old Stone 4461 – Best with High Heat Resistance
- 4. NerdChef NC-SS25 – Most-Durable
- 5. Love This Kitchen LTK-PIZZA-R16 – Best with Core Convection Technology
- 6. Emile Henry 787514 – Best with 10-Year Guarantee
- 7. Heritage Black Ceramic – Lightweight
- 8. Cuisinart CPS-013 – Most-Affordable
- 9. Wilton 2105-0244 – Best with Chrome Lifting Rack
- 10. Solido SYNCHKG100421 – Highly Compatible